KarMel Scholarship 2006

 

Winner of the “Written” Category

“Letter to My Son”

By Lisa Nagel - NY

 

 

Desciption of Submission: “My letter to my son, Ethan, about my journey with his other Mom as a lesbian couple and all o the trials and tribulations of life as a lesbian couple with a child.  Also my hopes and ears of him as he grows up with two moms.” - Lisa

 

 

Biography:  Lisa will be attending Morrisville State College as a freshman.  She is pursuing a nursing degree.

 

 

Why Karen and Melody Liked It:  This was a very heart felt personal letter telling about the emotions and experiences of raising a child as a lesbian couple.

 

Did you enjoy reading this lettter?  Then feel free to send a message to Lisa at: lisasphotofx@aol.com

 

 

 

 

March 8, 2006
“A Letter To My Son”

 

My Dearest Ethan,
 
There are so many things that I would like to say to you, wish I could say to you, and that I can not say to you.  I will begin by saying, however, that I love you with all of my heart.  You will never fully understand how much you saved my life. 

 

Our story begins on September 11, 2001.  (You will learn about this date in school.  It is the day that the United States was attacked by terrorists.)  On this day, your other Mom and I met for the first time.  She drove from New York to Maryland to meet me face to face for the first time since we met on the internet.  We hit it off instantly.  Not only did we hit it off, but your Pop-Pop liked her as well.  Someday, you will understand how large of an accomplishment this was.  I moved up to New York with her about 2 weeks later.  We faced a lot of hardships in our first 7 months together, as I was the first woman that she had ever been with.  No one knew that your Mom was a lesbian.  The hardships got the better of us and we ended up taking a break from one another.  We were separated for 8 months.  During that time, we dated other people.  However, we never lost contact, even when we were forbidden to speak.  We ended up back together again and we moved to Maryland.  There are always hardships in a relationship, and we experienced many of them.  However, we both knew that we were together for the long haul, so there was no need wasting our time on petty things.  Both of us did a lot of growing up.  We established our goals in life, both as a couple and individually.  Our main goal as a couple and mine, personally, was you.  We decided to have a child together.  We discussed every aspect of our decision to have you.  We talked about how our lives would change, if our family and friends would be supportive, if we could do it and still accomplish our other goals, and most importantly… how life would be for you.  After months of discussion, and a year of financial preparation, we decided that it was time.  I got pregnant with you in August of 2005.  I found out the day after your Mom’s birthday.  After taking 2 pregnancy tests a day for 2 weeks, it finally showed positive.  That night, I went to the hospital where one of my friends worked in the lab and had her do a blood test to confirm it.  The blood test was positive as well.  We were so excited!!  There are no words for the way that I felt.  You were my dream come true.  We told everyone at our work, (we both worked for the same hospital) and told all of our friends.  The next step was to tell our families.  I called your Uncle Donnie (my brother) and told him first.  He was shocked and was so happy.  He always wanted me to have a baby and make him an Uncle.  He came right over to our house and rubbed my belly and said, “There’s a baby in there!”  Next we told your Mom-Mom.  She was happy as could be.  She said that she always knew that no matter what, I would be a mother someday.  A couple of nights later, we went to your Pop-Pop and Na-Na’s house to tell them.  We were so nervous and did not know how to tell them.  A couple of their friends were over and we were all sitting around the table just talking.  When a break finally came in the conversation, I blurted out, “Guess what?! I’m pregnant!”  I didn’t quite get the response that I had hoped for.  Your Na-Na said, “Yeah right.”  Your Pop-Pop just dropped his jaw and didn’t say anything.  I got up and ran outside and started crying.  Your Mom stayed in the house and confirmed to everyone that I was not joking.  Your Pop-Pop came outside to talk to me and told me that he was sorry and that everyone was just shocked.  (No one even knew that we were planning to have you.)  He hugged me and told me that he was happy if I was happy.  We went back in the house and everyone said congratulations and next time, to prepare them before I blurt out something like that.  The last people we had to tell was your Mom’s family.  They were planning to come down to Maryland from New York to visit the next weekend.  We decided to wait and tell them then.  When they got to our house, it was pretty late in the evening, but we couldn’t wait any longer.  We sat them all down in the living room and your Mom told them.  They were happy and congratulated us.  It was pretty un-eventful.  The next day, however, your Mom’s father was not the same.  He finally made the statement that you would, “Never be a Harding.“  This crushed your Mom and I both.  We had met our first brick wall that comes with being lesbian parents.  Now, we had to get through the pregnancy.
 

 

Another couple of weeks went by and life took a major turn.  Your Uncle Donnie committed suicide.  It happened on the morning of September 26, 2005.  I got the phone call that your Pop-Pop had found him.  That was my deepest and worst fear, come true.  Your Uncle Donnie and I were more than brother and sister.  We were truly best friends.  He had lived with your Mom and I several times and he and I were always together.  Most of all, he was supposed to play such a huge part in your life.  That was the darkest time in my life.  If it weren’t for you, I would not have survived.  My first answer for all of the pain I was experiencing was to do the same thing that he had done.  However, I believe that everything happens for a reason, and you were my miracle.  You weren’t even the size of a pea yet, and already I knew that you were something special and you became my strength and will to survive.  I thank you for that from the bottom of my heart.  Without you, I am not too sure of where I would be.  Finally, after a couple of weeks, I was ready to return to work.

 

I was working on the Pediatric Unit in the hospital and your Mom worked in the Emergency Department.  All of our co-workers knew that we were an item and knew all about the pregnancy.  Most of them were very supportive.  One of your Mom’s co-workers had her own opinion though.  She approached your Mom and asked her, “With everything that kids have to go through these days, how can you be so selfish to add this to your own child?“  Your Mom was floored and crushed.  That was the next big brick wall.  Both of us are always professional at work.  Our jobs were to help patients and their parents on a daily basis.  Therefore, to make sure that they were always comfortable, we chose not to share our personal life with them.  Sometimes, that was not always easy. People automatically assume that because I was pregnant, I had a husband.  I was always asked what my husband did and I would respond that I did not have a husband.  Then, they would follow with, “Well how about your boyfriend?”  I would answer that I did not have a boyfriend.  After that, usually I was met with blank stares or an awkward moment.  I was trying to be professional.  One patient went further as to ask me, “Well who are you pregnant by?”  I, being professional and proud of who I am, responded, “My partner and I are having this baby together.”  The woman was really shocked and did not ask any other questions after that.  However, she acted awkward around me for her remaining stay in the hospital.  Again, somewhat of a brick wall. 
 

 

The months went by very slowly.  It seemed like an eternity.  We had your room ready for a baby to move in by the time I was about 4 months pregnant.  I finally reached the 9th month and I was huge.  Everyone kept telling me that I looked like I could pop any day.  I loved to hear that, but the days kept passing and there was no popping.  I was 2 weeks from my due date when I got some unusual cramping and went into the hospital for a checkup.  Your heartbeat was dropping a little bit but the nurse and doctor did not seem worried so they sent me home.  I spent the next 2 days on the couch crying because I just knew that something was wrong with you.  I went in the next day for my OB appointment and the doctor said that I still had another week at least and that everything was okay.  I still had a bad feeling.  I looked up how to induce labor yourself and I ended up drinking castor oil the next night.  After being in the bathroom for 2 hours, I fell asleep.  I woke up about 2 hours later having contractions.  Your Mom and I walked around the block for like another hour and timed the contractions.  Finally, we decided to go to the hospital.  When we got there, the nurse examined me and said that I would probably walk for an hour and then go home.  Then, she noticed that your heartbeat kept dropping and my contractions were only a minute apart.  She left the room and when she came back, she said, “Change of plans, the doctor wants you in a room and he will be here in ½ hour to break your water.”  Well, all of that happened and when he broke my water, you had a bowel movement already which meant that you were in distress.  They gave me a drug to induce my labor and it did not work.  They waited for me to fully dilate for like 9 hours and then finally decided to take you by C-section.  At 6:00 pm on May 4, 2006, you were born.  You weighed 8 pounds and 4 ounces and were 21 inches long.  You were healthy and beautiful and everyone loved you. 
 

 

We came home a couple of days later and had so many visitors to come and see you.  Everyone said how beautiful you were and they all held you.  My favorite times, however, were when it was just the three of us.  You, me and your Mom have so many wonderful times together.  I just wish that you could remember them later in life.  I also wish that other people could see those times and see the connection that you made with both of us… not just me, as your birth mother.  We both love you so very much.  You are our son.  You ended up not just touching our lives, most of our family became empowered by you.  Just like you got me through your Uncle Donnie’s death, you turned out to be a ray of sunshine to the entire family.  Everyone looked at you as their strength to make it, especially your Pop-Pop.  You are truly a miracle to all of us.
 

 

Now, you are growing so fast.  You change daily.  You are crawling all over the place and are on the verge of walking.  You have everyone wrapped around your adorable little pinky.  I, as your mother, worry about you constantly.  I worry about your future and about so many other things, I can not even name them all.  My biggest fear for you is knowing that, at some point, you will have to experience pain.  The world is full of it.  Though some of it is inevitable, like death of a loved one, most of it can be prevented.  Ethan, this world can be a cruel place.  You are a wonderful person already!!  I can see it and so can many others.  The world is your playground and you can do ANYTHING that you set your mind to.  People may pick on you or hurt your feelings about our family.  I heard this on a movie: Ellen DeGeneres said, “Kids get teased about one thing or another, you can’t prevent that.”  I just hope that your family, which is different from other families, is the only thing that you get teased about.  That way, it is not you that the kids are picking on, it is your Mom and I.  That means that you are doing okay in life!  Don’t feel like you ever have to defend us.  We made this choice for you and for us, and we did so with the utmost confidence.  We think about you and worry about you with our every breath.  You are the center of our universe and we will do anything and everything in our power to give you the life and the tools for life that we can. 

 

I love you more than you will ever understand and so does your Mom.  You are my miracle and you saved my life son!  I thank you for that, and I thank you for being you.  Enjoy your life! I know I am enjoying it!!

 

        My Undying Love Forever,
            Mom
                                      

 

   
In the picture, I am on the top, my partner Mindy has the dark hair, and of course Ethan!

 

 


I chose to write this letter for a couple of reasons, I found that it amazed me to see it on paper.  I would also like Ethan to have a copy one day.  My main reason was to show people that though some families are different in one way or another, we all go through the same trials and tribulations of life.  Some are more extreme than others, but all in all, we share the same emotions and experiences.  I also hope to show that Ethan, and any other child should not be singled out because of their family.  No child asks to be born, they/we all have to make our way through life using what we are given. 

 

 

 

Did you enjoy reading this lettter?  Then feel free to send a message to Lisa at: lisasphotofx@aol.com

 

Back